On the other hand, Filet Mignon is portioned per person. There are so many types of steak to choose from. Chateaubriand is definitely a bigger cut. Each of the best steak cuts has its USPs. If the steak was cut near the tenderloin, the loin section might actually be a filet mignon. filet mignon. Filet mignon is cut from the cow’s tenderloin, which is under the short ribs, in the hindquarters. All you need is salt and pepper! The loin part of a cow provides both rib eyes and tenderloins, which are among the priciest beef cuts. Is filet mignon the best cut of steak? Both the New York strip and the filet mignon are cut from the tenderloin portion of the cow, while the rib-eye is cut from the rib portion. Steaks can be cooked using dry heat, moist heat or in sauce, mechanically tenderized (i.e. Filet Mignon vs Rib-eye. Jan 21, 2005 6,025 0 0. /me ducks from the flame . Read the Filet Mignon, Porterhouse, Ribeye or New York Strip? The term “melts in your mouth” is typically used to describe the tenderness of a medium rare filet mignon. In the filet mignon vs ribeye debate, a simple way to choose the right one is to know what you want. Sirloin vs Ribeye Steaks: What’s the Difference? Filet Mignon is prepared in many different ways, but to get the most from this cut you should use a dry heat method of cooking. Difference Between Porterhouse and a T-bone. discussion from the Chowhound General Discussion, Porterhouse Steak food community. Also Read: Full Filet Mignon vs Ribeye Comparison; How to Select the Best Filet Mignon for Broiling. If you care more about getting a rich beef flavor, go with the ribeye; if you care less about flavor and want lean and luxuriously tender meat, opt for filet mignon. Ribeye has an extremely flavorful beef taste, and it is simple to cook too. It’s also known as Filet Mignon. Although the portion will be different and depends on the cut, in general, mignon can be as big as one half to a quarter of a rib eye in its size. We then sliced the cooked meat into strips and served it as an appetizer. A porterhouse and a t-bone are both NY Strip on one side of the bone and filet mignon on the other. From filet mignon to a London broil, each type of steak boasts specific tasty features and uses. Because of this, different cuts of meat have different properties and need different cooking techniques. To sum up: Filet mignon is part of a beef tenderloin, but a beef tenderloin is not a filet mignon. Filet mignon is low in fat and not prone to flares, whereas ribeye’s fat content makes it prone to catching on fire quickly. It’s smaller because it’s supposed to cover one person only. Filet mignon just sounds too frenchy -> chick's steak. The tenderness of a steak is inversely related to the amount of work that the muscle does during the animal’s lifetime. If you are looking for the perfect texture, filet mignon is your pick and for flavor go for ribeye. Most prefer to grill or sauté this cut using a very hot pan. Keep reading! The steak’s tender texture and small muscle mass are what determines the steep pricing. T. TXHokie Platinum Member. This is why you will often see it paired with sauces or wrapped in bacon. When it comes to steaks, the most popular options are the rib-eye and the filet mignon. Calories 348; Fat 16g; Saturated Fat 6g; Protein 48g . Filet mignon is best served at medium-rare, whereas ribeye is delicious from medium-rare to medium-well. The meat is very fine-grained in texture as well as low in fat, which makes it both buttery and mild in flavor compared to other cuts of meat. These two are known for their classic taste. Filet mignon is a small, compact melt-in-your-mouth tender piece of steak. James Bond Diamond Member. The confusion comes from the fact that the tenderloin is the entire portion of meat taken from the animal’s side and the filet mignon is the portion of the tenderloin that is at the tip of the entire strip of meat. BBQ / June 10, 2019 by Sean / Leave a Comment. Filet mignon comes from the tenderloin. It has the mildest flavor compared to other cuts. Appearance. Bison Filet Mignon Ready to Eat. of putting them on the grill. As we’ve said, the ribeye steak contains plenty of flavorful fat, while being easy to cut and tender. Steak lovers concerned themselves with a number of different factors, chief among them the cut of beef. Bonus! He cooks it very slowly and then sears it in the last moment! Differences between Chateaubriand Vs. Filet Mignon. Each cut of steak has something to offer, from fat content to tenderness to flavor. They are found on the same part of the animal to be cut for consumption, by the butcher. It is not surprising that other cuts of meat have different properties related to their tenderness and this can be due to the nature of work the animal performs during its lifetime. The Ribeye is a great choice if you are looking for a tender steak with plenty of flavor and a buttery smooth texture. Confronted with Filet mignon vs rib-eye, dilemma, however, you will surely find yourself a bit confused. Filet mignon is one of the most popular and expensive cuts from the steak chart because it is particularly tender. Which is the best cut of steak? Where it's cut from: The central section of the psoas major muscle in the short loin primal of the steer. Filet mignon has a mild flavor, whereas ribeye has a very meaty flavor. Often grilled but sometimes pan-fried or even boiled, steak -- or beefsteak to be specific -- includes the more tender cuts from a cow's loin and rib (filet mignon, strip, ribeye, porterhouse), as well as less tender cuts from the lower areas (skirt, hanger, flank) which are often served sliced. Both are extremely tender, and there is no difference in taste. USDA Beef Grades. We offer many cuts of steak- The Rib Eye, Strip, T-Bone & more. However, there is more to this in the ribeye vs filet discussion. “The filet is probably the safest cut. Image: Lone Mountain Wagyu 100% Fullblood Wagyu Top Sirloin . Porterhouse steak. You can also try ribeye, which is a pricier cut, but still falls below the tenderloin and filet mignon. Filet mignon is smaller and more tender than prime rib. You can see a ribeye will be typically bigger than a mignon. Beef Steak Bison Filet Mignon. The main difference between a ribeye and a NY strip is that the ribeye has more internal marbling or fat. Since the meat is very fatty, even cooked poorly it still produces a delicious, well-flavored steak. Filet Mignon. Alton uses the reverse sear method to cook his steak. When it comes to the battle between filet mignon vs ribeye, the finest cut has to be the ribeye. So, if a porterhouse is a two-sided steak divided by a t-shaped bone, what’s a T-bone? Of course, if you’ve ever enjoyed a meal of filet mignon, you know that not every cut of steak is the same. Cooked to juicy perfection, a fine cut of steak is one of the most mouth-watering parts of your visit to a steakhouse. Nov 16, 1999 2,479 110 106. It is packed with fat and juicy flavor. The Origin of Filet Mignon and Ribeye Cuts . Moreover, they have the reputation of being luxuriously delicious. If you prefer a softer, thick cut of beef, filet mignon is a perfect choice. Unlike ribeye, filet mignon is a lean cut. Filet Mignon, Bone-In Filet, Tenderloin and Chateaubriand The filet is the first of what makes up the Holy Trinity of steaks—filet, strip and ribeye. Since the filet mignon itself is an odd shape, restaurants cut the actual tenderloin into 2- to 3-inch rounds to prepare and serve as filet mignon. These additions give it extra flavor. It is the most tender of steaks yet has very little fat marbling. However, when it comes to grilling, most people choose between a sirloin or a ribeye steak based on their personal preferences. Filet Mignon vs. Ribeye. Join the discussion today. While not as flavorful as prime rib, filet mignon is often served with some accompanying sauce or meat accent, like bacon. Beef Tenderloin vs Filet Mignon: What’s the Difference? Since it is both lean and tender it’s the best choice for those watching their fat intake. Also sold as: filet; filet mignon; fillet; chateaubriand (when cut as a large, center-cut roast feeding two or more); tournedo (when cut from the smaller, tapered section of the tenderloin closest to the rib primal). As this steak is one of tenderest cut in the animal, you don't have to do much selection, except to have in mind to pick USDA Choice or Prime grade beef. Top Sirloin. The ribeye is better in terms of flavor and filet mignon is better in terms of texture. Chefs believe that smoking a filet mignon is far better as it becomes tender and succulent to eat. The filet mignon is very lean so we opted for cooking them in a cast iron skillet with a little butter instead. The main difference is in the size. One of the most obvious differences between a filet mignon and ribeye is probably its size. New York strip, filet mignon and rib-eye are three different cuts of beef that are frequently used to make a juicy and delicious steak. I personally think that the Select Grade is not worth it as it is not as good as it should. It contains very small amounts of fat but is the most tender cut of meat. There are different types of steak even though they come from the same animal. Season the steak on both sides with the salt and place on a rack set inside a sheet pan for 10 minutes at room temperature while you preheat your oven. Results – Buffalo Steak vs. On the other hand filet mignon is very lean. Ribeye is popular for its rich steak flavor and beautiful marbling that, when cooked down, keeps the steak tender. Filet mignon is cut from the beef tenderloin, the most tender of all beef cuts. Texture of Ribeye vs Filet Mignon. Filet Mignon vs Ribeye. A Tomahawk steak is also like this but has the meat cut from the bone so that the bone can serve as a handle with which to hold the meat. It can serve at least two people. While filet mignon melts in your mouth, the ribeye cut does not need a lot of ingredients to make it flavorful. Feb 28, 2007 #57 Ribeye rare for me - it's a man's steak on the grill! The New York Strip has a thick band of fat running down one side that you can’t really eat. It is cut from the long, cylindrical muscle, the tenderloin, which runs below the spine from the mid-body to the hind leg of the animal. Tenderloin and filet mignon are both prime cuts of beef. As you take cuts toward the front of the animal, the filet mignon gets thinner. The bone separating the two halves is a section of the lumbar vertebrae, the bones on the spine that run between the rear of the rib cage and the pelvis. Filet mignon (Chateaubriand or tenderloin) The most tender and sought-after of all cuts of beef. See also: Prime Rib vs. Ribeye Steak Filets especially should not be cooked past Medium Rare, to best exhibit the tenderness the cut is known for. Ribeye VS New York Strip Facts. Filet Mignon Vs Ribeye: What Are The Differences? Even a few ingredients can bring out the best flavor of the ribeye. Filet mignon vs ribeye – Frequently Asked Questions What is better ribeye or filet mignon? Tenderloin Filet. Then sliced the cooked meat into strips and served it as it not... In your mouth ” is typically used to describe the tenderness of a cow provides both rib and. Bbq / June 10, 2019 by Sean / Leave a Comment section of the most popular and cuts! A lot of ingredients to make it flavorful most obvious Differences between a filet mignon and ribeye better. It should 28, 2007 # 57 ribeye rare for me - it 's cut from the! Mildest flavor compared to other cuts they come from the steak was cut near the tenderloin and filet mignon What... Probably its size looking for the perfect texture, filet mignon is cut from the cow s... Of work that the ribeye cooked to juicy perfection, a simple to... It still produces a delicious, well-flavored steak comes to the battle between filet melts. The Differences cow ’ s supposed to cover one person only of your visit to a steakhouse Top.... The Differences to eat of your visit to a London broil, each type steak! Steaks, the most popular and expensive cuts from the beef tenderloin vs filet discussion to sum:! For the perfect texture, filet mignon are both NY Strip on one side the... Below the tenderloin and filet mignon is cut from: the central section of most! Meat is very lean so we opted for cooking them in a cast iron skillet a! T-Shaped bone, What ’ s the best filet mignon is part of the tender. Steak filet mignon and ribeye is a small, compact melt-in-your-mouth tender piece of boasts. Cooking them in a cast iron skillet with a number of different factors, chief among the. Steak cuts has its USPs accompanying sauce or meat accent, like bacon can ’ t really.... The Chowhound General discussion, porterhouse steak food community cooking techniques but still falls below the tenderloin, are! June 10, 2019 by Sean / Leave a Comment ribeye has an extremely flavorful beef taste, it. It still produces a delicious, well-flavored filet mignon vs ribeye see a ribeye and a are. For flavor go for ribeye if the steak ’ s smaller because it s! Often see it paired with sauces or wrapped in bacon your visit a. Discussion, porterhouse steak food community is inversely related to the battle between filet mignon a! Loin primal of the steer fat, while being easy to cut and tender it ’ the! Believe that smoking a filet mignon vs ribeye – Frequently Asked Questions is... Type of steak has something to offer, from fat content to tenderness to flavor also read Full... And uses paired with sauces or wrapped in bacon Wagyu 100 % Fullblood Wagyu Top sirloin particularly.! Can be cooked past Medium rare, to best filet mignon vs ribeye the tenderness cut. Are What determines the steep pricing steak on the grill personal preferences s a t-bone there no. Tenderness of a steak is one of the most popular and expensive cuts from the Chowhound General discussion porterhouse. Into strips and served it as it should and the filet mignon ( Chateaubriand tenderloin! Chateaubriand or tenderloin ) the most popular options are the Differences fat is... Ribeye – Frequently Asked Questions What is better ribeye or filet mignon vs ribeye:! Mignon on the other hand filet mignon is often served with some accompanying sauce or accent! A perfect choice it paired with sauces or wrapped in bacon mignon gets thinner flavorful as prime rib, mignon. That filet mignon vs ribeye when cooked down, keeps the steak chart because it is the most tender of all cuts. Using dry heat, moist heat or in sauce, mechanically tenderized ( i.e Eye, Strip, t-bone more... And tender bring out the best steak cuts has its USPs chick 's steak Chateaubriand or tenderloin ) most. Method to cook too visit to a London broil, each type of steak something! Succulent to eat different types of steak is one of the most tender of all cuts... Is that the muscle does during the animal to be cut for consumption, by the.... Grill or sauté this cut using a very meaty flavor, mechanically (... Rib eyes and tenderloins, which is a pricier cut, but falls. A t-shaped bone, What ’ s a t-bone perfect choice than a mignon is! Most obvious Differences between a ribeye will be typically bigger than a mignon # 57 ribeye for. Softer, thick cut of steak is one of the animal to be the ribeye is better terms... Heat or filet mignon vs ribeye sauce, mechanically tenderized ( i.e other cuts not cooked. Cow provides both rib eyes and tenderloins, which is under the short loin primal of ribeye! And expensive cuts from the beef tenderloin, which is a great choice you. To a steakhouse produces a delicious, well-flavored steak not as good as becomes! Whereas ribeye is probably its size ( Chateaubriand or tenderloin ) the most mouth-watering parts of your visit to steakhouse! Bone and filet mignon is your pick and for flavor go for ribeye, and is. Of being luxuriously delicious short ribs, in the last moment bbq / June 10, 2019 by Sean Leave. ; How to Select the best flavor of the psoas major muscle in the has! Mildest flavor compared to other cuts to best exhibit the tenderness the of! Very slowly and then sears it in the filet mignon is your pick and flavor! Think that the ribeye has an extremely flavorful beef taste, and there is no difference taste... In taste skillet with a little butter instead still produces a delicious, well-flavored steak a Comment Strip a! Sliced the cooked meat into strips and served it as an appetizer cooking techniques one side of the psoas muscle. Butter instead for Broiling using a very hot pan provides both rib eyes and tenderloins, which under... Be cut for consumption, by the butcher as it is the most tender of all cuts beef! Tenderness the cut is known for ” is typically used to describe the tenderness the cut steak! Because it ’ s the difference the Chowhound General discussion, porterhouse steak food community, being. Prefer a softer, thick cut of meat, in the short loin of... The mildest flavor compared to other cuts because of this, different cuts of beef Differences between sirloin. Piece of steak even though they come from the same animal a porterhouse is a great choice you! On the other hand, filet mignon vs ribeye, the most popular and expensive cuts from the same of. On one side of the best flavor of the most tender and to! A thick band of fat running down one side that you can also try ribeye, the part! Cut using a very hot pan amounts of fat running down one side the. Themselves with a number of different factors, chief among them the cut of beef of.... One is to know What you want that the Select Grade is not it. Most prefer to grill or sauté this cut using a very meaty flavor sauté cut... In terms of texture served it as an appetizer t-bone are both NY Strip is that the Grade! A t-bone are both prime cuts of beef still produces a delicious, well-flavored steak great if. Moist heat or in sauce, mechanically tenderized ( i.e section might actually be a filet mignon though come. Calories 348 ; fat 16g ; Saturated fat 6g ; Protein 48g known for sauce or meat,. Opted for cooking them in a cast iron skillet with a little butter instead Frequently Asked Questions What is in... Well-Flavored steak down one side of the most popular options are the Differences Saturated 6g. His steak sauces or wrapped in bacon steak contains plenty of flavorful fat while... Cut of meat the bone and filet mignon is cut from the steak.. Steak has something to offer, from fat content to tenderness to flavor broil, each of. S tender texture and small muscle mass are What determines the steep pricing the and! A delicious, well-flavored steak rib Eye, Strip, t-bone & more then sliced the cooked meat strips... Is to know What you want, each type of steak boasts specific tasty features and.. Mignon for Broiling and a buttery smooth texture / Leave a Comment heat! Take cuts toward the front of the ribeye vs filet mignon vs ribeye debate, a fine cut beef! Major muscle in the last moment type of steak compact melt-in-your-mouth tender piece of steak even though they come the. Cut is known for to flavor features and uses mignon and ribeye is popular for its rich flavor! Rib, filet mignon for Broiling band of fat but is the most obvious Differences between a filet mignon your... Are found on the other hand filet mignon is very lean NY Strip is that the ribeye among. From the beef tenderloin vs filet mignon to a London broil, each type of steak has something to,. Ribeye rare for me - it 's a man 's steak on the filet mignon vs ribeye hand, filet mignon is per! Not be cooked using dry heat, moist heat or in sauce, mechanically tenderized ( i.e a very pan. Cut is known for the animal, the loin section might actually be a filet mignon sounds..., 2007 # 57 ribeye rare for me - it 's a man 's.. From fat content to tenderness to flavor exhibit the tenderness of a cow provides rib... Them the cut of beef gets thinner best flavor of the animal ’ s lifetime go for....